“Tell me, brethren, in the fear of God, do you regard the
success of your labors, or do you not? Do you long to see it upon the souls of
your hearers? If you do not, what do you preach for; what do you study for; and
what do you call yourselves ministers of Christ for?” Richard Baxter
I do not intend this paper to be directed at any one pastor
and honestly not even at a number of pastors specifically. I write this to the
Reformed pastorate in general based on experience and what I have witnessed on
a macro level throughout my life; and especially since I became saved.
The passage that I intend to dive into is found in 1 Tim.
4:12-16. We start here because the qualifications for this office have been,
though woefully ignored in far too many churches, well covered. This paper
assumes that you are qualified to be a pastor based on the qualifications
presented to us in the Pastoral Epistles; if you are not, as only God, you, and
your local body can attest to, then this paper is not intended for you since,
quite frankly, you should resign your post. But for those that are rightfully
called to be pastors in our churches I pray that this paper will be edifying to
you and informative to the laity in order to encourage all of us to be seeking
what best glorifies God and edifies His people as laid out in His Word.
“[…] be an example to the believers in word, in conduct, in
love, in spirit, in faith, in purity.”
¨ [Paul] informs [Timothy] what are
the true ornaments; not external marks… but soundness of doctrine and holiness
of life. When he says, by speech and conversation, the meaning is
the same as if he had said, “by words and actions,” and therefore by the whole
life… The only way of procuring reverence is, by excellent virtues, to guard
ourselves against contempt. John Calvin
¨
[You will be an example] if thou
so livest as to be a just pattern unto Christians, imitable by them in word,
in thy common and ordinary discourse, (for he speaks not of his being a pattern
only to other ministers, but to believers in the generality,) not
talking frothily or profanely, or idly or impertinently, but seriously and
gravely, but things that are good, to the use of edifying, that it may
administer grace to the hearers. In conversation; and in all thy converse
with men behaving thyself justly, and [comely], and gravely. Matthew Poole
¨
Observe, those who teach by their
doctrine must teach by their [life], else they pull down with the one hand what
they build up with the other: they must be examples both in word and
conversation. Their discourse must be edifying, and this will be a good
example: their conversation must be strict, and this will be a good example. Matthew
Henry
Take heed to yourselves, lest your example contradict your
doctrine, and lest you lay such stumbling-blocks before the blind, as may be
the occasion of their ruin; lest you unsay with your lives, what you say with
your tongues; and be the greatest hinderers of the success of your own labors.
It much hindereth our work, when other men are all the week long are
contradicting to poor people in private, that which we have been speaking to
them from the Word of God in public… but it will much more hinder your work, if
you contradict yourselves, and if your actions give your tongue the lie, and if
you build up an hour or two with your mouths, and all the week after pull down
with your hands! This is the way to make men think that the Word of God is but
an idle tale, and to make preaching seem no better than prating. He that means
as he speaks will surely do as he speaks. One proud, surly, lordly word, one
needless contention, one covetous action, may cut the throat of many a sermon,
and blast the fruit of all that you have been doing. Richard Baxter
I have noticed an increasing trend for pastors to think
their personal life is somehow separate from their ministry. While it is true
that every nosy person in every church shouldn’t be obliged it doesn’t mean
that your life is not to be examined in general both at the pulpit and away
from it. I mentioned the qualifications earlier for being a pastor and have
heard people say that it would be almost impossible for a man to fulfill those
qualifications, which is true… and that is the point. In fact, that point is
being carried on here. Not just your eloquence on Sunday is up for examination
as a pastor, your general character is always under scrutiny whether you like
it or not. A normal man would not be able to handle such microscopic
examination but you men have passed an extremely difficult test of character
and with all of your might you must maintain and improve upon the character you
had when you began. You are a practical model for pious living to every single
one of your congregants. But it doesn’t stop there; you are the face of
Christianity to the lost world. They judge us quite often by your actions and
your way of living. Think otherwise? Ask the average lost man to name two
righteous pastors and he will more than likely fail to produce those names. But
ask that same man for two examples of pastoral frauds and Jim Baker and Ted
Haggard will be mentioned with little or no difficulty.
Some may be reading this and saying to themselves, “I know
this, what’s the point?” The point is that far too often you indeed know this
but ignore it. The point is that when it is brought to your attention that you
are having trouble in this area or that, too many of you don’t respond like
David did to Nathan saying, “I have sinned against the Lord.” (2 Sam. 12:13) No,
it is far more likely in this day and age that the charge is denied, dismissed,
and then the person that brought it up is attacked in order to silence their
voice from your conscience! I have seen this far too often. Gentlemen, you are
not above reproof, you are not above admonition and exhortation. Even if you
think they are wrong perhaps there is something in your character that is being
shown you by the Lord and you must pay heed just the same. We do not place you
into these positions to be trampled on and dominated by you; we put you there
to edify, instruct, and lead us by your teaching and example as we strive to
lead more pious lives ourselves! You should not be a stumbling block to your
people! I heard a pastor say one time that he watches movies and reads books
that he knows most of the church wouldn’t approve of. Then why are you reading
them? Is it a legalistic objection you expect which is worthy only to be
ignored? Or is there something you have obstinately engaged in knowing it is
wrong and an offense to the people you serve? Either way why would you do such
a thing and then boast of it knowing that it causes others offense? Is this
living by example in word and deed? I think it is more likely the opposite and
it is something that has become too familiar in our churches today; arrogance
in the clergy is an especially despicable trait since it almost always will
lead to indifference for their own behavior and faults.
“[…] give attention to reading...”
¨
He knew Timothy’s diligence, and
yet he recommends to him diligent reading of the Scriptures. How shall pastors
teach others if they be not eager to learn? And if so great a man is advised to
study to make progress from day to day, how much more do we need such an
advice? Woe to the slothfulness of those who do not peruse the oracles of the
Holy Spirit by day and by night, in order to learn from them how to discharge
their office! John Calvin
¨
Be diligent in reading the Holy
Scriptures, both for thine own instruction and for the edification of others.
Matthew Poole
¨
Those ministers that are the best
accomplished for their work must yet mind their studies, that they are
improving their knowledge. Matthew Henry
It is a palpable error of some ministers, who make such a
disproportion between their preaching and their living; who study hard to
preach exactly, and study little or not at all to live exactly. All the week
long is little enough, to study how to speak two hours; and yet one hour seems
too much to study how to live all the week. Richard Baxter
It is evident when we hear a sermon that is being
regurgitated from the past with no actual preparation for the Lord’s Day it is
being used on. It is evident when we hear the same quotes over and over again
that there isn’t a great deal of study being accomplished. It is evident when
we hear lackluster sermons that are a painful waste of our time. It is evident
when this becomes habitual that the pastor who is guilty in this does not care
about his flock or his charge before the Lord to shepherd that flock. But more
than all of that it is evident when there is no time in study for yourselves and
that is reflected in your daily living. Many, many men can put together an
academic presentation based on study, to whatever degree, and pass off a decent
result; but, I have yet to meet a man that can for any length of time pass off
a righteous life without personal study and a striving to grow in grace and
piety. That is true of all men, pastors included.
I have always wondered what was the great hindrance to a
pastor’s time that prevents solid study week in and week out. Is it just poor
time management or an utter disregard of responsibility? I am not even talking
about the week you are just off your game and didn’t deliver the best sermon of
your life. But the pastor, and you men know who you are, that continuously
delivers unprepared sermon after unprepared sermon should, in my estimation,
have to explain to his congregation why that is. It is a great disservice to
them that they come to be nourished and instructed and instead they hear drivel
that hurts their ears. More than that though, it is an affront to God that He
has clearly told you in His word to study diligently in order to feed His
children and yet you do not. Please don’t take lightly the Biblical commands of
how you are to function as a pastor or the harm you may do in neglecting to be
prepared. And please don’t think that anyone is fooled when you fail here, they
may not always say something but make no mistake about it, they recognize it.
Perhaps in a church such as Joel Osteen’s you could get away with this as long
as every so often you told the people that God wants them to be rich; but not
in a church that truly desires to grow in the Lord.
“[…] to exhortation, to doctrine…”
¨
Lest it should be thought that
careless reading was enough, he, at the same time, shows that it must be
explained with a view to usefulness, when he enjoins them to give earnest
attention “to doctrine and exhortation;” as if he enjoined him to learn in
order to communicate to others. It is proper, also, to attend to this order,
that he places reading before doctrine and exhortation;
for, undoubtedly, the Scripture is the fountain of all wisdom, from which
pastors must draw all that they place before their flock. John Calvin
¨
[…] to exhort others to their duty
there described, or to comfort others from arguments fetched thence… to
instruct others in the principles of religion. Matthew Poole
This now explains why there must be a diligent study of the
Scriptures and why it is so offensive when it is obvious there has not been
such. It is not only for your personal growth, as important and necessary as
that is; it is to bolster your ability to skillfully present the word of God to
the people of God and the world. If you do not spend time in diligent study
then you should have no expectation that you are actually preaching the word of
God. If that be the case then it is as William Hendriksen says, “[…] if there
be no pulpit reading, exhorting, and teaching,
divine worship is a
misnomer… Timothy, then, must
continue to devote his attention to these
important matters.” If true for Timothy then it is certainly true for all
pastors. If you are not studying and preparing then you are also not exhorting
and teaching, and if all of that be true then you are not leading your people
in the worship of God, whatever else it may be it has strayed from that.
“[…] meditate on these things; give yourself entirely to
them, that your progress may be evident to all.”
¨
The greater the difficulty in
faithfully discharging the ministry of the Church, so much the more ought a
pastor to apply himself earnestly, and with his whole might; and that not only
for a short time, but with unfailing perseverance. Paul therefore reminds
Timothy that this work leaves no room for indolence, or for slackening his
labors, but demands the utmost industry and constant application… [Timothy]
ought to labor to this purpose, that by his agency the edification of the
Church may be more and more advanced, and that corresponding results may be
visible; for it is not the work of a single day, and therefore he should strive
to make daily progress. John Calvin
¨
Let these things be the business
of thy thoughts… be in them, let them be thy whole work, not thy work by and
by, but they chief and principal business. Matthew Poole
¨
[…] Timothy must be nourished on
the words of the faith, and must train himself for godly living; that he must
so conduct himself that no one will despise [him]; that he must not neglect but
must exercise and cultivate his special gift… “Be in them with your whole heart,
with all your soul; be completely wrapped up in them.” […] if Timothy…
devote[s] himself completely to his task, as indicated, all… will take
note of his spiritual and professional advancement, to the glory of God.
William Hendriksen
¨
Ministers are to be much in
meditation. They are to consider beforehand how and what they must speak. They
are to meditate on the great trust committed to them, on the worth and value of
immortal souls, and on the account they must give on the last. Ministers must
be wholly in these things, they must mind these things as their principal work
and business… By this means their profiting will appear in all things, as well
as to all persons; this is the way for them to profit in knowledge and grace,
and also to profit others. Matthew Henry
As our people must be ‘doers of the word, and not hearers
only;’ so we must be doers and not speakers only, lest we ‘deceive our own
selves.’ A practical doctrine must be practically preached. We must study as
hard how to live well, as how to preach well. We must think and think again,
how to compose our lives, as may most tend to men’s salvation, as well as our
sermons. When you are studying what to say to your people, if you have any
concern for their souls, you will oft be thinking with yourself, ‘How shall I
get within them? And what shall I say, that is most likely to convince them,
and convert them, and promote their salvation?’ And should you not as
diligently think within yourself, ‘How shall I live, and what shall I do, and
how shall I dispose of all that I have, as may most tend to the saving of men’s
souls?’ Richard Baxter
It is not enough that you do the bare minimum expected of
you as a pastor. This is a special job that requires men of exceptional
character to perform the duties required therein. In order to accomplish that
you must be wholly invested into your ministry. 100 percent of your effort is
required at all times, on all days, in all surroundings. You cannot ever let
your guard down for even a moment. You are a prime target for the devil and he
is constantly in the business of leading you astray. Your character must shine
forth in reliance on God to sustain you in spite of impossible odds. It is not
easy, we know that, it is not intended to be. But you are not working for a reward
that can be measured in bank statements and applause, your reward is from God
Himself and will last an eternity. Be busy with the things of God and the work
He has given you the privilege of performing; and make no mistake about it, it
is a privilege indeed. Let this work consume you for your profit and for the
profit and edification of the Church.
“Take heed to yourself and to the doctrine… for in doing
this you will save both yourself and those who hear you.”
¨
It is no ordinary spur to excite
the thoughtfulness of pastors, when they learn that their own salvation, as
well as that of the people, depends on the industry and perseverance with which
they devote themselves to their office… Our salvation is… the gift of God
alone, because from Him it proceeds, and by His power alone it is performed;
and therefore, to Him alone, as the author, it must be ascribed. But the
ministry of men is not on that account excluded, nor does all this interfere
with the salutary tendency of that government on which, as Paul shows, the
prosperity of the Church depends… If thus a good pastor is the salvation of his
hearers, let bad and careless men know that their destruction must be ascribed
to those who have the charge of them; for, as the salvation of the flock is the
crown of the pastor, so from careless pastors all that perishes will be
required. John Calvin
¨
[…] thus thou shalt do what in
thee lieth to save thine own soul, and also to save the souls of others to whom
thou preachest, or among whom thou conversest. Matthew Poole
¨
God promises a special reward to
His faithful ministers, yes, to all His faithful witnesses; and threatens with
severe punishment the unfaithful ones. William Hendriksen
Take heed to yourselves, lest you live in those sins which
you preach against in others, and lest you be guilty of that which daily you
condemn. Will you make it your work to magnify God, and, when you have done,
dishonor Him as much as others…? O brethren! It is easier to chide at sin, than
to overcome it… As Peter saith to every Christian in consideration of our great
approaching change, ‘What manner of persons ought we to be in all holy
conversation and godliness!’ so may I say to every minister, ‘Seeing all these
things lie upon our hands, what manner of persons ought we to be in all holy
endeavors and resolutions for our work!’ This is not a burden for the shoulders
of a child. What skill doth every part of our work require! – and of how much
moment is every part! To preach a sermon, I think, is not the hardest part; and
yet what skill is necessary to make the truth plain; to convince the hearers,
to let irresistible light in to their consciences…, to drive sinners to a
stand, and make them see that there is no hope, but that they must unavoidably
either be converted or condemned – and to do all this, as regards language and
manner, as beseems our work, and yet as is most suitable to the capacities of
our hearers… It is a lamentable case, that in a message from the God of heaven,
of everlasting moment to the souls of men, we should behave ourselves so
weakly… [that] sinners [are] rather hardened than converted; and all this
through our weakness and neglect! How often have carnal hearers gone home
jeering at the palpable and dishonorable failings of the preacher! How many
sleep under us, because our hearts and tongues are sleepy, and we bring not
with us so much skill and zeal as to awake them. Richard Baxter
This is the culmination of these verses; this is the fruit
that will be evident for those that are obedient to its commands. There are
very real ramifications to what you do as a pastor that far outweigh what the
normal man has to deal with. Some have entered the ministry with no apparent
understanding of what the gravity of their calling is. Perhaps still others
lost it along the way. But pastors, for your sake and the sake of the church we
need you to regain it. You are going to have to give an answer for blessing or
harming the people of God and I certainly wouldn’t want to be on the wrong end
of that answer. The souls of men have been entrusted to you and that is a
magnificently honorable and frightening gift. If we look down our noses and
condemn men like Bernie Madoff for ripping people off with money they entrusted
to him, how much more so will God frown upon you when you have been found to be
ripping Him off of souls he has entrusted to you? A pastor who diligently gives
himself to his duties has a pious congregation as his crown; for a pastor who
flippantly goes through the motions
it would be better for him that a
millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in the depth of
the sea.
Summary:
Pastors, the people of God need you badly. We need the
instruction and exhortation that should come from you. We need to see that what
you preach you live and that the picture of Christian living is exemplified in
your life. I am not saying you are expected to be perfect, but an utter
disregard for how you affect others is not advisable for your sake or the sake
of those that interact with you. Your behavior is expected to be exemplary just
as your character has the same expectation in coming to your office in the
first place. Your language should not be vile in any way, you should not be
engaged in things that carry with them even a possibility of staining the office
you hold, your reputation is necessarily one of the most important tools you
are given by the Lord. When you so carelessly disregard how men view you it
shows how little you value the office you hold.
I have spoken to a number of people who perceive that the
elders (teaching and ruling) are tending towards a Catholic attitude when it
comes to how they view themselves in relation to their people. In many cases,
though thankfully not in all, a charge can longer be made against either class
of elder because the initial reaction is that they rally the troops and attack
with a vitriol you would expect only from a lost person. Church discipline is
given to silence and intimidate, people are kicked out of churches without
warning or due process, people are blackballed to the point that they leave
altogether of their own accord hoping that something better will appear at the
next church. This arrogance and lack of regard for the saints committed to your
charge overflows beyond the interaction during church service. Social media for
all of its advantages is a remarkable magnifier of a man’s true heart. When
face to face almost all of us will put on a show of amiability, but put a cloak
of anonymity in front of us and such pretense falls away. Some of the most
vicious attacks I have seen and some of the most consistently disagreeable men
I have had the misfortune of encountering on the internet have been pastors. They
rule with a sense of unapproachable superiority in their own churches and when
questioned by men that are not intimidated by them or in fear of being outcasts,
their impatience and distemper becomes readily evident. I recently saw a man
announce with joy that he had received a call to a new church and based on my
interactions with him in the past felt genuine sorrow for the people that were
getting ready to sit under his care. That shouldn’t be the case! Pastors should
inspire confidence and we should want them to be near us, but increasingly this
is not the case.
Shepherd your flock with the heart of Christ as your model.
Christ was willing to give all to recover one lost sheep (Matt.
18:10-14). Yet today many pastors are more
concerned with whether or not they will be able to transform their local body
into the next mega-church and as long as they are putting bodies in the pews
see no reason to have a shepherd’s heart in seeking after the one. You must be
willing to give all you are and all you have to fulfill the office you hold. If
you are not willing to do that with each and every congregant you have then you
should perhaps start questioning whether or not you should hold the office in
the first place. Self-preservation has no place in what you do; you are there
for God and His people exclusively. Serve them well and leave the rest to the
Lord.
Time is only a marginal excuse to justify the lack of time many
pastors spend with their people, in visiting them, in instructing them, and in
growing them in the faith; yet time is so often used as the excuse that
supposedly none can dare question. Nowhere in the word of God can I see where
it says to be on twenty committees at Presbytery, to take four weeks of
vacation a year, to be a guest speaker at every conference on earth, or to
publish a relentless amount of articles. There is nothing wrong with those things
ultimately if they can be done while you are actually spending an appropriate
amount of time shepherding your flock. If they interfere with that then you
must abandon some or all of these things to focus on what really matters. Sure
you will not be a well known pastor from coast to coast and the accolades will
dim in comparison, but
thy Father which seeth in secret Himself shall reward
thee openly. John Calvin refused to rest for fear that the Lord would come
back and find him idle; John Owen likewise worked himself to death; Matthew
Henry preached six days a week traveling from church to church under extreme
pain due to his long battle with gout. Are you willing to do the same? Or is a
40 hour work week the criteria whereby you will judge that you have done
enough?
Please consider the deplorable state of the modern Church.
Please consider yourself and what you can do to effect godly change and reform
for you are such a vital cog to Christianity. We need godly men to rise up and
lead with character. We need men who with unwavering certainty will insist that
orthodoxy and orthopraxy are essential to the health of the Church and will
settle for nothing less. We need qualified men to exhibit the character
necessary to care for and grow the Church. I implore you to consider what I
have presented here and, if you are wanting, to cast yourself before the Lord
and correct these things for in so doing
you will save both yourself and
those who hear you. Amen.
Sources Cited:
¨
John Calvin, Commentary on
Timothy, vol. 21, pp 113-118, Baker Books
¨
Matthew Poole Commentary, vol. 3,
pp 783-784, Hendrickson Publishers
¨
William Hendriksen Commentary,
vol. 10, pp 158-160, Baker Academic
¨
Matthew Henry Commentary, pp 1888,
Hendrickson Publishers
¨
Richard Baxter, “The Reformed
Pastor,” pp. 63-70, Banner of Truth